We have presented a comprehensive data of similarities of style and you may posts between Baronio's texts and the ones we are going to today ascribe to Vigano II, to acknowledge these blog off 2020-2021 regarding totally different of those of Vigano I, of one's age 2018-2019

(Emmanuele Barbieri-Roberto de Mattei) Who is the actual writer of this new blog regarding Archbishop Carlo ? Let's try to render a means to fix issue that we increased into the Corrispondenza Romana ( here ), beginning with a yes method: the research and review of writings toward messages off almost every other experts traceable on the internet. What inside medical jargon is named stylometric lookup.

Well then, the research off lexical and you can stylistic points prospects us to just you to definitely it is possible to copywriter: “Cesare Baronio,” otherwise “Baronius,” publisher and creator, from 2010 in order to 2020, of your own blog Opportune Importune.

Preferred to Baronio and you may Vigano II is the software to help you progressives of your conditions “counter-church,”, “conciliar sect” ( here and here ) or “innovators” ( here and here ).

Vatican Council II try a couple of times laid out by each other once the an enthusiastic “idol.” To possess Baronio, until “this new conciliar idol is actually overthrown, with the unhappy memories of the architects, it would be impractical to discipline new highest priests with besieged Rome having 50 years” (, right here ). Vigano II, inside the current Interview to the Liturgy, including defines Vatican II because the an enthusiastic idol and you can, for example Baronio, set good Vatican II-Novus Ordo Missae equivalence.

” Vigano II produces that “the latest architects of this liturgy” have been “prelates will suspected regarding owned by Freemasonry, notoriously modern” ( here ) ; Baronio consequently speaks off “a rite composed by notoriously modern and you may Masonic prelates” (, here ).

The fresh new instructions of one's the brand new liturgy to Baronio is “released missals whoever form is compared to an excellent plotline to refer so you're able to for versions from the individuals national languages” (, here ). To own Vigano II, these liturgical instructions “is actually developed since an outline, good plotline susceptible to virtually skilled stars searching for societal applause” ( right here ).

Getting Baronio “the fresh new offertory vanishes totally to make means for a great Jewish prayer with a good pantheistic taste” (, here ); Vigano II talks of that it prayer since “Talmudic offertory” ( here ).

Baronio and you may Vigano II, when speaking about the newest Novus Ordo out-of Paul VI, always discuss about it new “reformed rite” otherwise “Montinian rite

Considering Vigano “the fresh thus-called ‘Golden-haired chasuble' regarding forms that preceded the latest Council, especially in France, has been that type of poncho and that after the Council was enacted away from with the united states since the a recuperation of original mode,” but is “a historical plus liturgical counterfeit” ( right here ). Baronio composed one: “the newest conciliar chasuble are an effective horrid poncho who has got absolutely nothing to perform on planeta explained from the Saint Charles Borromeo (Instructionum fabricae, 1557), http://besthookupwebsites.org/tr/amolatina-inceleme/ and this we find depicted in a lot of frescoes, paintings, miniatures and you will enamels because Old” (, right here ).

Vigano denounces “tries to make reformed liturgy respectable that have fairly useless procedures away from maquillage” ( right here ). Baronio writes one “businesses away from routine maquillage for the Novus Ordo can be found in our very own view condemned regarding the almost all circumstances for the most unhappy shipwreck” (, right here ).

One can possibly continue forever, but what issues extremely outside the spoken coincidences is similar build, hence expresses a beneficial smug liturgical, theological, and you can historical training one to Baronio features flaunted having 10 years into his web log it is entirely missing in the 2 years of personal statements by the Vigano I.